Several years ago, a Canadian musician’s $3500 Taylor guitar was severely damaged by baggage handlers from United Airlines. When Dave Carroll couldn’t get the airline to take responsibility for what they had broken, he made a music video that was viewed by millions on YouTube, creating a public relations nightmare for United.
Wikipedia reports, “It was widely reported that within four weeks of the video being posted online, United Airlines’ stock price fell 10%, costing stockholders about $180 million in value.” (That would’ve bought over 51,000 replacement guitars!)
I bring this up because a couple that lives near us in Las Vegas had a terrifying incident at a local Starbucks. Lauren Weyand writes on Nextdoor:
“5 or 6 teenage kids came in shirtless, shoeless, and screaming profanities at each other…using incredibly vulgar language and pulling all of the food products out of the fridge section with no intention to buy anything. They asked the cashier for large water, one for each of them. Each of them was given water. They were heading out of the store.
My husband saw them line up — waters in hand — and said, ‘Ready, go!’ Before I knew it, I was hit in the head with a water cup. Two large cups of water doused our computers and us. We were startled and overwhelmed by what had happened. The whole store acknowledged the incident and asked us if we were okay. The Starbucks staff said nothing and started mopping up the mess. Nobody contacted the police or managers to ask for help with the situation that had just occurred.”
Weyand continues that she and her husband later returned to Starbucks to speak to the manager about what had happened. They were told they could not have video of the incident, and no police report had been filed because an employee got tired of waiting for the police to answer the phone, so they hung up and didn’t try again. The manager then led them to the door and told them more information would be forthcoming.
- Look, we could turn this issue into a political or generational topic and press hot buttons all day long. Let’s not – that isn’t what this commentary is about.
At the current point, the Weyands must buy two new laptop computers, as neither of the ones they were using at Starbucks is now working because of the water damage. The Starbucks helpline – using the term “help” a bit loosely here – told them the case was closed and had been resolved, even though nothing was truly handled. From Weyand’s perspective, Starbucks has chosen the profane, shirtless troublemakers who threw water in their store over two loyal customers.
When I contacted Lauren Weyand, she confirmed that Starbucks remains silent – which she understandably perceives as a lack of concern and commitment for their customers.
In the frequently negative world of social media, some are questioning if Starbucks has any liability in this matter. I’m not a lawyer, so I don’t know the correct answer – but the important issue is that we should care less about liability and be more concerned about the customer experience.
What did United do in the wake of the PR disaster over the music video, “United Breaks Guitars”? As I relate in my new book, “The Ultimate Customer Experience,®” they licensed the video from Carroll to use in their training curriculum. They’ve hired him to speak at meetings for them to emphasize the importance of the customer experience.
And United’s share price has gone from $3.25 when Carroll’s video was the hottest thing on YouTube to closing today at $53.34! That’s what happens when you listen to your customers, learn from your mistakes, set things straight with those you have wronged, and focus on the Ultimate Customer Experience!
Starbucks may save a couple of grand by staying silent and not offering the Weyands replacement laptops, hoping they’ll just give in and give up. But just like United discovered how they could be “penny wise and pound foolish,” we’ve seen from experience that ANY business, no matter their size, can get on the wrong side of the public and lose millions when basic empathy and concern for the customer is ignored.
Every customer has a right to presume they aren’t going to have water thrown at them and have their computers ruined because they chose to do business with you.
So, what should Starbucks do? I’d suggest the minimum is that they apologize, replace the laptops, and provide the Weyands with a couple of gift cards with handsome amounts attached.
(They might also increase security so that shirtless, shoeless individuals can’t enter their stores in violation of health ordinances…and provide the store’s video to the police so they can press charges.)
Starbucks should learn from its mistake. Because they didn’t get it right, they should take advantage of the opportunity to make it right. If they fail, they may discover more people than a nice couple here in Vegas who are beginning to question if it’s worth a trip to get coffee from them, as opposed to their competition, if the experience is going to be so inferior – even problematic.
(Full disclosure: I’ve had the privilege of working with United and consider their Chief Customer Officer, Linda Jojo, a friend.)
The Ultimate Customer Experience® book is now available – get yours today!
